I’m wondering if there is some unwritten book of code for improv houses/basement comedy shows. For example:
People’s Improv Theatre: West 29th Street, above a sushi restaurant
Upright Citizens’ Brigade: West 26th Street, next to a Gristedes
PIT admission: $5
UCB admission: $5-$8
PIT theatre access: hike upstairs to purchase tickets
UCB theatre access: watch line snake downstairs as you wait for your tickets
PIT theatre gripes: a wee bit chilly
UCB theatre gripes: supportive beams that hinder visibility
PIT VIP service: buy warm beer at ticket counter
UCB VIP service: buy warm beer at ticket counter
PIT claims to fame: photos on walls, ranging from Steve Buscemi to Mariska Hargitay to Lisa Gastineau, you know, of the notorious Gastineau girls…what do you mean you never watched that show?
UCB claims to fame: everyone
PIT attire: frayed jeans, old tee’s, vintage Chuck T’s (yes! uncool factor), throwback corduroys, unwashed hair…
UCB attire: unwashed jeans, throwback tee’s, old Chuck T’s, frayed hair….
PIT courses: $333 dollars for weekly introductory improv course
UCB courses: $325 dollars for weekly introductory improv course. If you purchase a Starbucks before class, it all evens out.
The PIT, however, hosts an event called The Liar Show, in which the director invites three people to tell their most absurd, outlandish, and literally unbelievable stories to an audience, while images of infamous Liars flash in the background (Nixon, Bill O’Reilly, James Frey to name a few). Afterwards the audience members are allowed to ask questions, in attempts to poke holes through the stories, and then vote on who they believe is the Liar. The winners get PIT T-shirts.
Last night we were ushered in just a minute before 7 p.m. and were ushered out barely forty five minutes later. Remember in college when your well-meaning but rambling professor would say, “Oh dear…I’m afraid I’ve run over and the next class has to come in?” That’s basically what happened. The PIT’s schedule is so packed that the show wasn’t given enough time.
I once read an article in a women’s magazine, before I quit women’s magazines (along with designer coffee and a bad boyfriend), that said that people who lie always give too many details. Armed with this info, I thought I would be able to nab the liars. But all three stories were very detailed. I kept thinking, “You can’t make this stuff up.”
The first storyteller, Brian, told a really funny story about his attempt to renovate an independent theater in Haverhill, Massachusetts, with hopes to subsequently revitalize the town. His plans were foiled when he kept giving away free tickets, to “plant the seeds” of marketing. Then he enlisted the help of a comedy group named “Mrs. Potato Head” who performed a skit entitled “Sore From Fucking.” Brian was possibly lying.
The second storyteller, named Sara, recounted her experiences trying to find a New York City apartment on craigslist with her salary as a store greeter for Banana Republic. She found a dream deal in Park Slope. But the tenants - her future roommates - were an attractive forty-something investment banker and his teenage girlfriend named Seng-Yi who didn’t speak a word of English and who, by the way, cleaned the house naked, per his request. The story sounded crazy, but having gone through my share of craigslist encounters, I couldn’t peg Sara as the Liar.
Finally, the last potential Pinocchio, named H.R., began by telling us about his obsession with the movie “The Graduate”. Then he told a story about his affair with an older woman he met during his first summer in New York, and how he fell so head over heels in love with her that he didn’t go back to school in Wisconsin the following year. He proposed and she gently pointed out that they were at very different places in their lives. He moved out of her apartment and wound up finishing school. The whole thing was not unbelievable. But he was so verbose - his language was almost - and I hate this word - “flowery” - that I figured he might be fudging the details and thought maybe he wouldn’t have gotten laid if he was a hardwood floor plank.
Only a few people asked investigative questions, and one of the questions was “H.R., have you ever told your girlfriend that story?” to which H.R. replied, “No.” Turns out the girl who asked that question was his girlfriend, and she didn’t seem happy.
The director then took our ballots, announced that The Liar was H.R., and handed us our t-shirts. The T-shirt was well worth the five dollar ticket. But I would’ve liked to have seen the event stretch a little longer.